6992 people
- Pic, Mary Ann
- Pickerell, Benjamin
- Pickerell, John
- Pickering, Levi
- Pickett, J. L.
- Pickrell, Patty
- Pierce, Valentine
- Pierre, John
- Pilbrew, Elizabeth
- Pilbrew, Ephraim
- Pile, Elizabeth
- Pile, Henry
- Piles, Joseph
- Pinckney, Christina
- Pinke, Rap
- Pinknam, Molly
- Pinkney, William
- Piper, James
- Pittman, Henry
- Plowden, Edmund
- Plowden, Francis
- Plowden, Henrietta
- Plummer, Gerard
- Plummer, John
- Plummer, Samuel
- Plummer, Sarah
- Plumsell, Stephen B.
- Plumsell, Thomas
- Plunkett, John
- Plunkett, Maria
- Poesy, Elizabeth
- Polk, William
- Polley
- Pollitt, Levin
- Pollitt, William
- Polly
- Polly
- Polly
- Polly
- Pomery, William
- Pompey
- Ponsonby, Richard
- Poole, John
- Poor
- Poor, Jr., Joseph
- Poor, Nathaniel P.
- Pope, Collimore
- Pope, Fielder
- Pophan, John
- Porter, Daniel P.
